Updated November 2026 | The Bulldog Law | California Criminal Defense
You have a constitutional right to represent yourself in a California criminal case. The rule comes from a California case, Faretta v. California, in which the United States Supreme Court held that a state cannot force a lawyer on a defendant who knowingly and voluntarily chooses to go without one. A person who does so is said to be appearing pro per, or pro se in federal court. The judge must allow it if you are competent, ask clearly and in time, and understand what you are giving up. Whether it is wise is a separate question, and in a criminal case the answer is almost always no.
People consider self-representation for understandable reasons: the cost of a lawyer, distrust of an appointed one, or a belief that no one else will tell their side properly. Our attorneys would rather a person make that decision knowing exactly how the right works and what the alternatives are.
Where the right comes from
The Sixth Amendment guarantees the assistance of counsel. In Faretta v. California (1975), the Supreme Court held that the same amendment implies the opposite right, to conduct one's own defense. The defendant in that case, charged with grand theft in Los Angeles, asked to represent himself because he believed the public defender's office was overloaded. The trial judge refused and the conviction was reversed. The Court was candid that most defendants are better off with a lawyer, and held that the choice still belongs to the accused.
The right to a lawyer remains the default. Under Penal Code 987, the court must tell a defendant at arraignment of the right to counsel and appoint one if the defendant cannot afford to hire one.
What a judge requires before granting a Faretta motion
- Competence. The defendant must be mentally competent. Under Indiana v. Edwards, a court may deny self-representation to a person who is competent to stand trial with a lawyer but, because of severe mental illness, is not able to carry out the basic tasks of presenting a defense alone. California courts follow that rule.
- A clear request. The request must be unequivocal. A remark made in anger after losing a motion, or a request made only as leverage to get a different lawyer, does not qualify.
- Timeliness. The request must be made a reasonable time before trial. After that point, granting it is within the judge's discretion.
- A knowing and voluntary waiver. The judge warns the defendant about the dangers of self-representation, usually with a written advisement form, and confirms that the defendant understands the charges and the maximum punishment.
The judge is not allowed to deny the motion because the defendant lacks legal training or because the judge thinks the decision is foolish. Wrongly denying a proper, timely request requires reversal of a conviction without any showing that the outcome would have been different.
When the court can say no, or take it back
|
Reason |
What it looks like |
|
Untimely request |
Made on the eve of trial or after trial has started, especially if a continuance would be needed |
|
Equivocal request |
Conditional or emotional statements; asking to be co-counsel |
|
Severe mental illness |
The defendant cannot carry out the basic tasks of a defense without counsel |
|
Purpose of delay |
A pattern of switching between lawyers and self-representation to postpone trial |
|
Serious misconduct |
Disrupting the courtroom, defying rulings, intimidating witnesses, or abusing jail privileges granted for case preparation |
What you take on
A pro per defendant is held to the same rules as a lawyer. The judge cannot give legal advice or help with the case, and the prosecutor's duty is to the other side. Alone, you would have to:
- Read and understand the police reports and other discovery, and demand what is missing.
- Research the law and write, file, and argue motions, including any suppression or dismissal motion.
- Find, interview, and subpoena witnesses, usually from custody if you are in jail.
- Evaluate and negotiate any plea offer, including consequences for immigration, licenses, and future sentencing that are not obvious from the offer itself.
- Conduct jury selection, make an opening statement, examine and cross-examine witnesses under the rules of evidence, and object at the right moments or lose the issue.
- Propose jury instructions and argue sentencing.
Two consequences are easy to miss. First, a defendant who represents himself or herself cannot later argue on appeal that the defense was incompetent. Second, everything you say in court as your own advocate is heard by the jury, and the line between arguing your case and testifying without being cross-examined is one judges police closely.
Pro per defendants in custody
A person in jail who is granted pro per status may receive limited privileges to prepare, such as law library time, additional telephone access, legal supplies, and in some cases court-funded investigator or expert services on a showing of need. These vary by county, are far short of what a law office has, and can be revoked for misuse.
Standby and advisory counsel
A judge may appoint a lawyer to sit in reserve. Standby counsel is ready to take over if the defendant gives up or loses pro per status. Advisory counsel answers legal questions when asked. Neither is guaranteed, neither runs the case, and the defendant remains responsible for every decision. California does not recognize a right to hybrid representation, in which the defendant and a lawyer share the work as co-counsel, although a judge can allow limited participation.
Better alternatives if the problem is your lawyer or the cost
- A public defender costs nothing. If you cannot afford a lawyer you are entitled to one. Public defenders are experienced trial lawyers; the common complaint is caseload, not ability. See public defender versus private attorney.
- A Marsden motion. If your appointed lawyer is not communicating, not investigating, or not competent, you can ask the judge to appoint a different one. The hearing is held without the prosecutor present so you can speak freely.
- Hiring counsel. Many private attorneys offer flat fees and payment plans; see what a criminal defense lawyer costs. If you are unsure whether your current lawyer is the problem, compare your experience with the signs of a bad criminal defense attorney.
- Limited help. In minor matters a lawyer can sometimes be retained for a single appearance or to review an offer.
The first chance to raise any of these is the arraignment, when the judge asks whether you have a lawyer.
When self-representation is more reasonable
The calculation is different outside serious criminal cases. Traffic infractions carry no jail and no right to appointed counsel, and many people handle them alone. Small claims court does not allow lawyers at the hearing at all. For civil, family, and other non-criminal matters, the California Courts Self-Help Guide provides forms and instructions. For any charge that carries jail, a criminal record, or immigration consequences, the risk of going alone is of a different order.
Frequently asked questions
Can you represent yourself in a criminal case in California?
Yes. Under Faretta v. California, a defendant has a constitutional right to refuse a lawyer and conduct his or her own defense. The judge must grant the request if the defendant is mentally competent, makes the request clearly and in time, and gives up the right to counsel knowingly and voluntarily after being warned of the risks.
What does pro per mean?
Pro per is short for the Latin in propria persona, meaning in one's own person. It is the term California state courts use for a person who appears without a lawyer. Federal courts and most other states say pro se, which means the same thing.
What is a Faretta motion?
It is a defendant's request to give up the right to an attorney and represent himself or herself. The judge questions the defendant, usually with a written advisement form, to confirm that the defendant understands the charges, the possible sentence, and the disadvantages of proceeding without counsel. If the requirements are met, the motion must be granted.
Can a judge deny a request to represent yourself?
Yes, in limited situations: the request is made too close to trial or during trial, it is equivocal or made in a moment of frustration, the defendant is not competent to conduct a defense because of severe mental illness, or the request is a tactic to delay the case. A judge can also end self-representation if the defendant becomes seriously disruptive.
Do you get a lawyer to help you if you represent yourself?
Not as a matter of right. A judge may appoint standby or advisory counsel, a lawyer who is available to answer questions or to take over if self-representation ends, but is not required to. A defendant has no right to act as co-counsel alongside a lawyer.
Can I change my mind and get a lawyer later?
Usually, if you ask early. Once trial is close or under way, the judge has discretion to refuse, considering the reason for the request, the stage of the case, and the delay it would cause. A defendant who gives up counsel and then loses cannot appeal on the ground that his or her own performance was inadequate.
What is a Marsden motion?
It is a request by a defendant with a court-appointed lawyer to have that lawyer replaced. The judge hears the defendant's complaints in a closed hearing and must appoint a new attorney if the current one is not providing adequate representation or the relationship has broken down so badly that ineffective representation is likely. It is the usual alternative to self-representation for someone unhappy with appointed counsel.
Is it a good idea to represent yourself?
In a criminal case, almost never. The prosecution is run by trained lawyers, the rules of evidence and procedure apply to you in full, and mistakes made at trial usually cannot be fixed on appeal. People who cannot afford a lawyer are entitled to a public defender at no cost, and people who are unhappy with an appointed lawyer can ask the court to replace that lawyer.
Related reading from our attorneys
- Public defender versus private attorney in California
- How much a criminal defense lawyer costs
- What happens at arraignment
Thinking about going it alone? Talk to a lawyer once before you decide
The Bulldog Law's criminal defense attorneys offer consultations to people weighing self-representation or unhappy with their current counsel. Call (888) 928-1609 or reach us online.
