Updated November 2026 | The Bulldog Law | California Post-Conviction Relief
Under California Penal Code 17(b), a judge can reduce certain felony convictions to misdemeanors. It applies only to wobblers, crimes that can be punished either way, and generally only when the person was given probation and not sentenced to prison. Once reduced, the offense is a misdemeanor for all purposes going forward: the person is no longer a convicted felon under California law, and in most cases the right to own a firearm returns. A motion can be made at sentencing or years after the case ended.
For someone with a single old felony, this is often the most valuable form of relief available, more useful in daily life than an expungement. Our attorneys usually file the two together.
Wobblers
California classifies crimes as felonies, misdemeanors, and infractions; our page on felonies and misdemeanors explains the categories. A wobbler sits between the first two. Its statute authorizes both a felony sentence and a county jail sentence of up to one year. Penal Code 17 provides that such an offense is a felony unless and until one of several events makes it a misdemeanor.
Several hundred California offenses are wobblers. Common ones include:
- Assault with a deadly weapon, Penal Code 245(a)(1).
- Domestic violence causing injury, Penal Code 273.5.
- Criminal threats, Penal Code 422.
- Grand theft, Penal Code 487, and receiving stolen property over the felony threshold, Penal Code 496.
- Second-degree (commercial) burglary, Penal Code 459.
- Unlawful taking of a vehicle, Vehicle Code 10851.
- Battery causing serious bodily injury, Penal Code 243(d).
- Resisting an executive officer, Penal Code 69.
- Identity theft, Penal Code 530.5, and forgery, Penal Code 470.
- Stalking, Penal Code 646.9.
- DUI causing injury, Vehicle Code 23153, and from 2027 a third DUI within ten years.
Crimes such as robbery, residential burglary, and most sales of controlled substances are straight felonies and cannot be reduced under this section. Our list of California felonies indicates which is which.
The five ways a wobbler becomes a misdemeanor
|
Subdivision |
When |
Who decides |
|
17(b)(4) |
At filing: the prosecutor charges the wobbler as a misdemeanor |
The prosecutor |
|
17(b)(5) |
At or before the preliminary hearing: the magistrate determines the offense is a misdemeanor |
The judge, often on the defense's motion |
|
17(b)(1) |
At sentencing: the court imposes a punishment other than state prison or a felony county jail term |
The judge |
|
17(b)(3) |
At sentencing or any time afterward: the court grants probation without imposing a prison sentence and declares the offense a misdemeanor |
The judge, on application by the defendant or probation officer |
|
17(b)(2) |
In juvenile commitments: the court designates the offense a misdemeanor |
The judge |
The route most people use after a conviction is subdivision (b)(3). It has no time limit. A person who finished probation ten years ago can still apply. The earliest route, charging as a misdemeanor, is a matter of prosecutorial discretion, and a defense attorney's early contact with the filing prosecutor can make the difference.
Who is not eligible
- People sentenced to state prison. If the court imposed a prison sentence, the offense is fixed as a felony.
- People who received a suspended prison sentence. When a judge imposes a prison term and suspends its execution during probation, a sentence has been imposed, and California courts have held that the offense can no longer be reduced under section 17(b)(3). When the judge instead suspends imposition of sentence and grants probation, the offense remains reducible. The difference appears in the minute order and should be negotiated at the time of the plea.
- People convicted of straight felonies.
Certain felony drug and theft convictions that are not wobblers can be reduced through a different law, Proposition 47, by petition under Penal Code 1170.18.
How a judge decides
The decision is discretionary. In People v. Superior Court (Alvarez), the California Supreme Court identified the relevant considerations: the nature and circumstances of the offense, the defendant's appreciation of and attitude toward it, and the defendant's traits of character as shown by behavior and demeanor, together with the general objectives of sentencing. In practice a post-probation motion is strongest when it shows:
- Probation completed without violations, or terminated early.
- Restitution, fines, and fees paid.
- No arrests since.
- Steady work, education, or family responsibilities.
- A concrete reason the felony is holding the person back: a job, a license, housing, or immigration.
- Limited harm in the original offense and a limited record before it.
A person still on probation can ask the court to end probation early under Penal Code 1203.3 and reduce the offense at the same hearing. See our probation guide.
What a reduction changes
|
Area |
Effect of a 17(b) reduction |
|
Status |
A misdemeanor for all purposes from the date of the order. The person can truthfully say he or she has not been convicted of a felony in most contexts |
|
Firearms |
Removes California's lifetime felony ban. Does not help if the misdemeanor carries its own ten-year ban or is a domestic violence offense subject to the federal lifetime ban |
|
Three Strikes |
A reduction after sentencing does not remove a strike. A wobbler made a misdemeanor at the initial sentencing is not a strike |
|
Future enhancements |
A reduced wobbler generally cannot be used as a prior serious felony for the five-year enhancement in a later case |
|
Professional licenses and employment |
Significant benefit: many disqualifications apply only to felonies |
|
Jury service and public office |
Removes felony-based restrictions |
|
Immigration |
Helpful in some situations, but federal immigration law applies its own definitions. Get advice before relying on it |
|
Sex offender registration |
No change. Registration requirements are not affected |
For firearm questions that a reduction does not resolve, see our page on restoring firearm rights. For noncitizens, see deportation consequences of criminal convictions.
Reduction and expungement together
The two remedies do different jobs. A reduction changes what the conviction is. An expungement under Penal Code 1203.4 withdraws the plea and dismisses the case, which helps with private employers. Filing them together, reduction first, produces a dismissed misdemeanor in place of a felony conviction. The Judicial Council's petition form covers both requests, and the California Courts self-help pages explain the paperwork. Some older records are also sealed automatically under the clean slate law.
The motion is filed in the court where the conviction occurred, with notice to the prosecutor, who may oppose. Many courts decide unopposed petitions on the papers; contested ones are set for hearing. A declaration from the petitioner, proof of completion of probation, and supporting letters should accompany the motion.
Frequently asked questions
What is a 17(b) motion?
A 17(b) motion asks a California judge to reduce a felony to a misdemeanor under Penal Code 17(b). It is available only for wobblers, offenses the law allows to be punished as either a felony or a misdemeanor. Once reduced, the conviction is a misdemeanor for all purposes from that point forward.
What is a wobbler?
A wobbler is a crime that can be charged and sentenced as either a felony or a misdemeanor. The statute for the offense provides both a state prison or county jail felony term and a county jail misdemeanor term of up to one year. Examples include assault with a deadly weapon, grand theft, second-degree burglary, criminal threats, and domestic violence causing injury.
Who is eligible to have a felony reduced to a misdemeanor?
A person convicted of a wobbler who was granted probation and was not sentenced to state prison. If a prison sentence was imposed, even one that was suspended while the person was on probation, the conviction generally cannot be reduced under section 17(b). Straight felonies, which have no misdemeanor alternative, are not eligible.
When can a 17(b) motion be made?
At several points: at or before the preliminary hearing, at sentencing, during probation, and after probation ends. There is no deadline after probation, so a motion can be filed years later. Many people file it together with a petition for dismissal under Penal Code 1203.4.
Does reducing a felony to a misdemeanor restore gun rights in California?
Often, yes. A reduction under section 17(b) removes the lifetime felony firearm ban under California law, and federal law generally follows the state's classification. Exceptions matter: some misdemeanors carry their own ten-year ban, and a misdemeanor crime of domestic violence carries a lifetime federal ban. A reduction is a stronger remedy for firearm rights than an expungement, which does not restore them.
Is a 17(b) reduction the same as an expungement?
No. A 17(b) reduction changes the level of the conviction from felony to misdemeanor. An expungement under Penal Code 1203.4 withdraws the plea and dismisses the case after the sentence is completed. They do different things and are usually requested together: reduce first, then dismiss.
Will a judge grant a 17(b) motion?
It is discretionary. The judge considers the nature and circumstances of the offense, the person's attitude toward it, and the person's character as shown by conduct since, along with the general goals of sentencing. Successful completion of probation, payment of restitution, no new arrests, and evidence of stable work and family life are the strongest support.
Does a 17(b) reduction remove a strike?
Not if it is granted later. Whether a prior conviction is a strike is determined as of the date of the conviction, so a wobbler that was a felony at sentencing remains a strike for Three Strikes purposes even after it is reduced. A wobbler that is declared a misdemeanor at the initial sentencing is not a strike.
Related reading from our attorneys
- Felony versus misdemeanor in California
- What it means to expunge a record
- List of felonies in California
Carrying an old felony that could be a misdemeanor? There is no deadline to ask
The Bulldog Law's criminal defense attorneys file 17(b) motions with expungement petitions in courts across California, and negotiate misdemeanor outcomes in pending wobbler cases. Call (888) 928-1609 or reach us online.
